McNairy County, TennesseeHistory Archives

Newspaper clipping

Big Shoes (no. 2)

This is the text of the clipping below, read from the picture by computer so it can be read aloud and searched. Old newsprint reads imperfectly, so some words may be wrong. Tell us if you spot one.

Newspaper clipping: Big Shoes (no. 2). Its text follows below.

Text of the clipping

it would be Uncle Billy Tilghman (Tillman). On the maps of a hundred years ago a small creek was marked and so known as Tilghman’s Branch. Sheriff Robert Lee’s great-grandmother was Mrs. Specie Tilghman (Tillman) Lee. She was born April 19, 1872 at Pittsburg Landing, Tenn. The old homeplace is located a short distance from Tilghman’s Branch near Shiloh.

Uncle Billy Tilghman’s name is spoken of in the company of Wyatt Earp, Bat Masterson and such people. In fact, Bill Tilghman was recognized as one of the West’s most capable Marshals. His career has been carefully documented and is recorded in the history books with a handful of the best lawmen who ever lived.

In a celebrated event at Dodge City, Kansas, Uncle Billy Tilghman participated in a very noted role. It seems that Dora Hand was the most gracious and beautiful lady in Dodge. Once Dora Hand had been a singer in Grand Opra. In the summer of 1878, Dora Hand was the queen of the Fairybelles and was prime entertainment for the cowboys who came into Dodge. She had seen Abilene and Hays during their hell roaring days. There arose a disagreement between Mayor Dog Kelly and Spike Kennedy and a fight followed. Kelley threw Kennedy out of the Alhambra Saloon. Kennedy left but meant to come back and square things. Later in October, Kennedy stole up to Kelley’s two room house and fired two shots through Kelley’s door in the direction of the Mayor's bedroom. The first passed over the head of Fannie Garretson. The second slug passed through a partition and killed Dora Hand, asleep in the room. Kennedy then rode wildly out of town

Marshal Wyatt Earp set out with Bat Masterson, Charlie Bassett and Bill Tilghman to bring Kennedy back. They chased Kennedy a hundred miles before running him down at Cimarron Crossing. When told he had killed Dora Hand, he grew morose and begged that they kill him. Masterson was the one who brought him down with a rifle slug into his arm. Back in Dodge they took four inches of bone from his arm - that was about the only price he ever paid for killing Dora Hand. His wealthy father got him free for lack of evidence. Dora Hand now sleeps in the Prarie Grove Cemetery north of town. She had the biggest and finest funeral the town ever saw. Wyatt Earp was there, also Bat Masterson as was the quiet mannered and handsome Billy Tilghman.

Uncle Billy Tilghman’s grandfather, Richard Tilghman 1747-1804, had migrated to Tennessee and lived there before the Tilghman’s moved westward to settle. Eventually Bill Tilghman became a top lawman in Oklahoma Territory. Bill Doolin was a noted outlaw whose horse pulled up lame when the Dalton’s planned to hit two banks simultaneously in Coffeyville, Kansas in 1892. Doolin set out for Oklahoma Territory when the Dalton’s were wiped out at Coffeyville. He organized what was to become the last great outlaw band in the west. Doolin and his gang run and robbed for four years. Doolin was a thief but not a bush whacker. In the spring of 1894, Doolin married a preacher's daughter. The romance didn’t hinder Doolin’s draw at the bank and 1894 was a big year for the gang. His cohorts were Bitter Creek Newcomb, Little Bill Raidler and Red Buck, an indian.

Jack, a member of the gang, was killed robbing a train in the spring of 1895. A little later Bitter Creek Newcomb and Charlie Pierce fell mortally wounded.

It was January of that year that Bill Doolin saved Bill Tilghman's life by keeping him from being shot in the back, Tilghman stopped at the Rock Ford on a bitter cold January night. He stepped into the dugout and saw only curtained bunks and an old man in a rocking chair, a rifle cradled in his arm. There was a brief exchange of words as Uncle Billy warmed his hands. Six winchesters was trained on his back when he turned. There was a long pause and finally Unce Billy said good night and eased out. As he left, Red Buck leaped up with a Colt .45 and tried to shoot Tilghman in the back. Doolin grabbed him and refused to allow him to shoot Tilghman. ‘‘Bill Tilghman is too good a man to be shot in the back,’’ Doolin said.

Tilghman continued to hound the Doolin gang. He found Little Bill Raidler at Mission Creek. Raidler came up a path to his log cabin just as the sun was setting. Suddenly Tilghman was standing in the doorway shouting for him to surrender. Raidler jumped and drew his Colt at the same time. He fired first knocking off Tilghman’s hat. Tilghman shotgun roared and Raidler was knocked back like he had been kicked by a mule. Raidler kept working his gun and shot the door facing around Tilghman to splinters. Tilghman then bandaged his wounds and carried him 30 miles to a doctor. Raidler was sent to prison and it was Bill Tilghman who helped him get a pardon when he developed locomotor ataxia from the wounds Tilghman had inflicted

Bill Tilghman took the noted Doolin at Eureka Springs, Arkansas. He went after Doolin by himself in a bath and a vicious fight followed. In packing up Doolin’s things, Tilghman found a small silver cup. ‘That's for my baby boy”’ the outlaw said. ‘‘I’ll see that he gets it,”’ said Tilghman.

At Guthrie, Oklahoma a crowd of 5,000 jammed the depot to see Tilghman return with Doolin. They ignored the brave lawman and cheered the outlaw. Doolin escaped jail and returned to his wife and the baby Tilghman had taken the cup to. It was Heck Thomas rather than Bill Tilghman who finally did Doolin in. The event occurred at Lawson, Oklahoma. Thomas waited for Doolin as he came down a trail in the moonlight, his Winchester cradled in his arm. A blast from Thomas’ shotgun dropped Doolin in his tracks. Thomas led a horse carrying Doolin’s body back to Lawson. Following along behind was a team and wagon carrying Doolin's widow and baby and few household goods, a coop of chickens and a turning plow, mute symbols of the life an outlaw had spurned but had at last tried to embrace. The items had been loaded for a new life, a new start, that never was to happen.

Uncle Billy Tilghman was the mild mannered quiet one. Never Vicious until provoked. He played a great role in the taming of Oklahoma Territory and lived to see it become a state. He died November 24, 1924 at the hands of a drunken young cowhand, whom he was about to arrest.

If Sheriff Robert Lee is to fulfill a family tradition . . . then Uncle Billy Tilghman’s will be big shoes to fill.

iPe 9).

Back to the Sheriff Robert K. Lee gallery